From my sister Sama: As many of you know, I went to Jordan and Palestine this summer with my Aunt and four cousins (the Ibrahims). They stayed another month in Jordan after I left and came back this week. This is my own family's personal experience with profiling...and just for anyone out there that thinks there might be just cause in their background, my Aunt (the one in the hijab) used to have top clearance as she was IT for the FBI, including on Sept 11 when she was detained by airlines while the gov't was flying her around to do security checks on their systems.
This is a real issue. This will only get worse. Besides any inconvenience or hardship this might cause us, there are far worse ramifications that are around the corner if this continues. Profiling doesn't work and there is extensive research to back this up. In this case, they detained a woman who previously had FBI security clearance, 3 peace activists and 1 musician who didn't even want to go to Palestine because he was afraid.
FOX NEWS CLIP WITH MY COUSINS AND AUNT


JFK illegally targeting Muslims, groups say
BY BRYAN VIRASAMI
Newsday Staff Writer
August 24, 2006
Muslim, Arab and South Asian passengers are being profiled by Homeland Security officers at Kennedy Airport, civil liberties groups said Wednesday, citing a New Jersey family that was detained and interrogated after a flight from Dubai last week.
The family, a mother and her 20-year-old twin daughters from Montclair, N.J., said they were plucked from the baggage area, held six hours without food or water by Customs and Border Protection agents and questioned about their views of Iraq.
Nahgam Alyaqoubi and her daughters, Arwa and Sumia Ibrahim, naturalized American citizens, said 200 other passengers of Arab, Muslim or South Asian backgrounds were detained on Aug. 15 in a roped-off area, days after the London bomb suspects were arrested.
The family joined officials from the American Civil Liberties Union and other rights groups at a news conference in the Manhattan office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations to condemn what they say has been an increase in racial profiling since the London plot was uncovered. They also criticized Rep. Peter King for what they said was profiling.
Arwa Ibrahim, who along with her sister is enrolled at Rutgers University, said they were born in Iraq and moved to the United States at age 5. She said the experience was disturbing because they were forced to sit on the floor without food or water and were treated rudely when they asked questions of the officers.
"It was a really humiliating experience -- humiliating because we were treated like animals," she said. "We were treated really horribly by the officers that were there, we were yelled at, we were told to get back, threatened with arrest and threatened to have to stay longer if we complained."
The ACLU and other rights groups said they planned to investigate this and several other complaints of profiling.
Lucille Cirillo, a supervisory Customs Border Protection officer in New York City, said the heightened alert after the London arrests means more passengers are scrutinized. She said the Orange Alert dictates that some flights get more attention.
Neither customs nor homeland security officers engage in racial profiling, she said. "But what I will say on the matter is our officers will scrutinize more closely individuals arriving from high-risk countries," Cirillo said.
On the complaints about lack of water, she said airlines are required to provide food and water to passengers even if they're off the plane and in the luggage area of the airport.
Katherine Metres Abbadi, executive director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, said recent comments from King were inflammatory.
"Why is Congressman King calling for a policy which has been tried and proven not to work and which has been disavowed by security experts?" she said.
King said he was speaking on the basis that the "next terrorist" will come from places like the Middle East or South Asia.
"First of all, it's not ethnic or racial profiling," King said Wednesday. "What I'm saying, though, is that screeners should have the right to ask additional questions of a person who belongs to a particular ethnic or religious group if members of that group have threatened the United States."
Copyright 2006 Newsday Inc.
source: http://www.newsday.com/news/local/newyo
August 24 2006, 03:50:33 UTC 5 years ago
What a wanker. I'm sorry this happened to your family.
August 24 2006, 04:08:56 UTC 5 years ago
xoxo
August 24 2006, 05:47:43 UTC 5 years ago
That said, the profile should be of young to middle aged males. I don't know about the muslim part, really. I mean, jose padilla didn't have muslim ancestry but still fit the profile of young male. Same with the taliban kid from Marin.
Do you really think searches should be entirely random? Does it really make sense? Who is kidnapping people? Blowing up planes, buses, subways, trains? Who is angry at the US? It sure isn't grandma.
I mean, the problem really isn't random. What's sad is that if you acknowledge that it's not random, a lot of innocent people such as your family are harassed, embarassed, and treated poorly.
If you disagree, I'd really like to hear your reasoning. I'm open to changing my opinion, but just saying, "experts say profiling doesn't work" doesn't convince me. There is a pattern. It may not be politically correct to acknowledge it, but that doesn't make it go away.
Thoughts?
August 24 2006, 12:36:55 UTC 5 years ago
Secondly, just because Grandma doesn't hate America doesn't mean her luggage wasn't compromised by someone who does.
Third, security through profiling compromises security through intelligence. Your standard Arabic As A Second Language student from Missouri isn't going to be able to infiltrate a terrorist network. The WTC bombing in 1993 was solved (and almost stopped, before the fact) by an Egyptian American who posed as a member of their cell while feeding information back to the FBI. The recent arrests in London were thwarted on the basis of a tip from a member of the Islamic community. Alienating the Arab and Muslim community is a civil liberties issue, definitely, but even if one doesn't care about that, it's also bad policy from a security standpoint. The CIA has been having a terrible time recruiting Arabic translators. Wonder why.
August 24 2006, 18:33:08 UTC 5 years ago
and to add to that...
I think the USA is always one step behind the terrorist. When they used box cutters, they banned box cutters, when they were going to use liquids, they ban liquids. The people behind these attacks are smarter than the USA because they understand how to manipulate things like racial profiling. You don't believe it when experts say that racial profiling does not work? Well forget the experts, use common sense and logic. Think about it. When I was younger there was this little corner store I would go to and buy soda, smokes, etc. Anyway the guy that worked there would ALWAYS stare at me like I was going to steal something...maybe it was my looks, maybe becuase I looked foreign. Something about me made him suspicious, no reason for it but that is how he was. I put up with it. But one day I got fed up and my very blonde American girlfriend and I went to the store and he continued following me with his eyes thinking that I was going to steal something. And you know what my girlfriend did while this dude was only paying attention to me? She robbed him blind! She stuck so much crap inside he shirt it was almost falling out and he never saw a thing! He even smiled at her when she left as he continued following me around his store...you see how it works? Racial profiling only does one thing-- it gives the bad guy an idea. If you are looking for an Arab terrorist then you will be blind forever. We ripped the guy from the store off and continued doing it all summer. His racial profiling helped us steal from him.August 24 2006, 18:43:24 UTC 5 years ago
Re: and to add to that...
Naughty habibi. The only time I ever shoplifted I went back the next day and paid for the stuff...But yes, he needed to learn that everyone is suspect. Trust nobody!!!!! Wasn't there a bomb inside a child's doll once?
I love you baba. (Now the FBI will come knocking again to ask me what I mean, no? )
av
August 24 2006, 11:37:48 UTC 5 years ago
August 24 2006, 14:08:53 UTC 5 years ago
the land of the free. they wish!
I am sorry this happened to your family, and I really can't see the logic sense in this! It's so easy to cover racism and discrimination up onder the veil of 'safety precautions'.Have you heard about what happened on Schiphol airport yesterday? An American plane was escorted back to Schiphol by two F16s, a few men where taken off board handcuffed, and authorities are not willing to explain anything. The men were presumably Muslim.
On september the first my friend from Cairo is taking a plane to Amsterdam Schiphol and now he's actually concidering cancelling his flight, because he has the Egyptian nationality, plus, he is muslim. He asked me for my advise on this matter, and I think Egypt is not a high risc country. I guess. But I don't want him to get into trouble.
What do you think about this?
Man, this needs to stop.
August 24 2006, 18:48:32 UTC 5 years ago
August 24 2006, 19:03:32 UTC 5 years ago
August 29 2006, 12:31:51 UTC 5 years ago
http://www.parkerstudio.com/AAW/JFK_stor
Not quite the same but not too different in tone really.